In learning about social innovation, we’ve been discussing how innovative approaches differ from more conventional state responses to social need, and to for-profit approaches. I’ve been reflecting on social change that happens outside of the context of NGO providers, government, and business. That is, practices where communities make their own change.
As a teenager, I learned about zines at around the same time I learned to code websites, and I was immediately drawn into the practice of published self-expression in both of those formats, unmediated by editors or other gate-keepers. I connected with a community of punk-influenced DIY publishing, and organised self-publishing community events and a non-profit distribution network. These initiatives were self-organised, funded through bootstraps methods like benefit shows (Debies-Carl, 2014, describes this punk fundraising practice in his book Punk Rock and the Politics of Place: Building a Better Tomorrow).
This kind of social initiative can be kind of unsustainable, personally exhausting and not as easily scalable as institution-backed programmes. However, it can be personally satisfying to engage in, and potentially more directly connected with human interests and needs. As my 23-year-old self noted: “A lot of corporate media (mainstream magazines, newspapers, ‘reality’ television) is really removed from the experience of real people, I think, and sells really stereotyped, normalised versions of what people are supposed to be like. At their best, zines are the opposite of that: published by all sorts of people for all sorts of people, from all different political perspectives and approachable.”
Here are:
Three things social innovation can learn from DIY punk practices
1. Don’t accept prevailing narratives
Mainstream culture, government policy, societal power structures tell stories about how we’re meant to behave. Jackson (2005) has long cautioned us against accepting the state’s limiting definitions of what “the reality is”. From a louder perspective, Bikini Kill sang about the stories that limit creative women: “They want us to think/ That to be a girl poet/ Means you have to die.” and “I’ve another good one for you/ We are turning cursive letters into knives.”
Reject popular ideas about “how things are”, especially if they’re based on limiting stories, or on sexist, racist, heteronormative (etc) ideas about whats possible. Fight inevitability; create counter-narratives. Build from there.
2. Make what you need, and start where you are
You have more than you know: skills, knowledge, relationships, insight. If you need something to happen, step up and do it.
i got a heart that’s true
i got some things i can do
i know that everything’s fucked up
but i ain’t ever, ever gonna shut up
– Heavens to Betsy, Nothing Can Stop Me
Use what you have. Prototype from your own understanding of what you, and people like you, need. It doesn’t need to be perfect, or polished. It just needs to be genuine.
Don’t wait for someone else to do it for you or give you permission. Respect the authority of your own experience.
3. Speak for yourself. Listen to others
Speak up when you need to. When it’s not about you, de-centre yourself from the narrative. Prioritise the voices that need to be heard.
(Hint: it’s usually not about you! Even when you’re in charge, have the humility to see that there’s a community supporting you, and you’re there to serve them.)
Sleater-Kinney on this: “I am not the captain/ I am just another fan.”
Listen from others, and learn. 23-year-old me again: “zines and the culture(s) surrounding them have made me think and continue to challenge my thought patterns, and have taught me so much about politics and identity and the world in general outside my little perspective on it… In some ways, social and political change only happens like that, through individuals learning and challenging themselves and encouraging those around them to learn.”
—
References
Dajska, E. (2012). How to make a zine. Retrieved from Rookie: http://www.rookiemag.com/2012/05/how-to-make-a-zine/.
Debies-Carl, J. S. (2014). Punk Rock and the Politics of Place: Building a Better Tomorrow. Routledge: USA.
Hanna, K. (1995). Bloody Ice Cream [Recorded by Bikini Kill]. On Reject All American [CD]. Olympia, Washington: Kill Rock Stars.
Heavens to Betsy. (1994) Nothing Can Stop Me. On Calculated [CD]. Olympia, Washington: Kill Rock Stars.
Jackson, M. (2005). The face behind the law: the United Nations and the rights of Indigenous peoples. Retrieved from New Zealand Yearbook of New Zealand Jurisprudence: http://www.nzlii.org/nz/journals/NZYbkNZJur/2005/14.html.
Sleater-Kinney. (1999). The End of You. On The Hot Rock [CD]. Olympia, Washington: Kill Rock Stars.
Small Print. (2005). Small Print Zine Fest 2005.. Retrieved from The Big Idea: https://www.thebigidea.nz/node/171277.
Zobl, E. (2003) Writing and distributing whatever I want!: An interview with Moira from Moon Rocket Distribution. Retrieved from Grrrlzines.net: http://grrrlzines.net/interviews/moonrocket.htm.




