Pamphleteering and DIY social change

table of zines

In learning about social innovation, we’ve been discussing how innovative approaches differ from more conventional state responses to social need, and to for-profit approaches. I’ve been reflecting on social change that happens outside of the context of NGO providers, government, and business. That is, practices where communities make their own change.

As a teenager, I learned about zines at around the same time I learned to code websites, and I was immediately drawn into the practice of published self-expression in both of those formats, unmediated by editors or other gate-keepers. I connected with a community of punk-influenced DIY publishing, and organised self-publishing community events and a non-profit distribution network. These initiatives were self-organised, funded through bootstraps methods like benefit shows (Debies-Carl, 2014, describes this punk fundraising practice in his book Punk Rock and the Politics of Place: Building a Better Tomorrow).

This kind of social initiative can be kind of unsustainable, personally exhausting and not as easily scalable as institution-backed programmes. However, it can be personally satisfying to engage in, and potentially more directly connected with human interests and needs. As my 23-year-old self noted: “A lot of corporate media (mainstream magazines, newspapers, ‘reality’ television) is really removed from the experience of real people, I think, and sells really stereotyped, normalised versions of what people are supposed to be like. At their best, zines are the opposite of that: published by all sorts of people for all sorts of people, from all different political perspectives and approachable.”

Here are:

Three things social innovation can learn from DIY punk practices

1. Don’t accept prevailing narratives

Mainstream culture, government policy, societal power structures tell stories about how we’re meant to behave. Jackson (2005) has long cautioned us against accepting the state’s limiting definitions of what “the reality is”. From a louder perspective, Bikini Kill sang about the stories that limit creative women: “They want us to think/ That to be a girl poet/ Means you have to die.” and “I’ve another good one for you/ We are turning cursive letters into knives.”

Reject popular ideas about “how things are”, especially if they’re based on limiting stories, or on sexist, racist, heteronormative (etc) ideas about whats possible. Fight inevitability; create counter-narratives. Build from there.

2. Make what you need, and start where you are

You have more than you know: skills, knowledge, relationships, insight. If you need something to happen, step up and do it.

i got a heart that’s true
i got some things i can do
i know that everything’s fucked up
but i ain’t ever, ever gonna shut up
– Heavens to Betsy, Nothing Can Stop Me

Use what you have. Prototype from your own understanding of what you, and people like you, need. It doesn’t need to be perfect, or polished. It just needs to be genuine.

Don’t wait for someone else to do it for you or give you permission. Respect the authority of your own experience.

3. Speak for yourself. Listen to others

Speak up when you need to. When it’s not about you, de-centre yourself from the narrative. Prioritise the voices that need to be heard.

(Hint: it’s usually not about you! Even when you’re in charge, have the humility to see that there’s a community supporting you, and you’re there to serve them.)

Sleater-Kinney on this: “I am not the captain/ I am just another fan.”

Listen from others, and learn. 23-year-old me again: “zines and the culture(s) surrounding them have made me think and continue to challenge my thought patterns, and have taught me so much about politics and identity and the world in general outside my little perspective on it… In some ways, social and political change only happens like that, through individuals learning and challenging themselves and encouraging those around them to learn.”

—

References

Dajska, E. (2012). How to make a zine. Retrieved from Rookie: http://www.rookiemag.com/2012/05/how-to-make-a-zine/.

Debies-Carl, J. S. (2014). Punk Rock and the Politics of Place: Building a Better Tomorrow. Routledge: USA.

Hanna, K. (1995). Bloody Ice Cream [Recorded by Bikini Kill]. On Reject All American [CD]. Olympia, Washington: Kill Rock Stars.

Heavens to Betsy. (1994) Nothing Can Stop Me. On Calculated [CD]. Olympia, Washington: Kill Rock Stars.

Jackson, M. (2005). The face behind the law: the United Nations and the rights of Indigenous peoples. Retrieved from New Zealand Yearbook of New Zealand Jurisprudence: http://www.nzlii.org/nz/journals/NZYbkNZJur/2005/14.html.

Sleater-Kinney. (1999). The End of You. On The Hot Rock [CD]. Olympia, Washington: Kill Rock Stars.

Small Print. (2005). Small Print Zine Fest 2005.. Retrieved from The Big Idea: https://www.thebigidea.nz/node/171277.

Zobl, E. (2003) Writing and distributing whatever I want!: An interview with Moira from Moon Rocket Distribution. Retrieved from Grrrlzines.net: http://grrrlzines.net/interviews/moonrocket.htm.

Choosing how to be

saturday coffee

Maber (2012) (YouTube video) describes the Ladder of Inference, first proposed by Chris Argyris. The model outlines how we interpret the situations we find ourselves in. It suggests that our minds climb through a sequence of steps (King, 2013) to make sense of things and take action. We take in our experiences, filter what we see as relevant, interpret what it means, make assumptions, draw conclusions, and form beliefs, which become the basis for our actions. By slowing down, noticing and questioning each of these steps, we can broaden our understanding of our situation, choose different ways of seeing, and start to see things from others’ perspectives.

A few years ago, I was lucky enough to attend the Public Health Leadership Programme. As part of a learning module on developing our leadership backbone, we learned a similar concept: the Catapult Storyline (Catapult, 2014). In this model, your worldview is made up of what you see, mediated by your internal stories (those patterns where you interpret experiences in a certain way, form explanations, and draw conclusions). Your experiences inform who you are (who you’re being in the world, which inform what you do. In turn, this informs the result you achieve.

We were invited to make a plan: who did we want to be in the world, to help us achieve the things we aspired to? What actions would we take, and what things would enable us or hold us back?

As a way of reflecting on the being question, I developed a reflective practice that I’ve found useful, when I manage to make the time for myself. It goes like this:

  1. Set a weekly recurring meeting in your diary, at a café near your work. It’s a meeting with yourself. However, don’t be put off by this. Treat it as a real meeting, carve out the time, be prompt, and give yourself your full attention.

  2. Order coffee; maybe some food. You’ll need: a notebook, a pen, your calendar for the previous and upcoming weeks, your mind. Put your phone away if you can.

  3. Answer this question with three words: how do you need to be to do what you need to do, in order to make the world better (or achieve whatever result you’re aiming for). Three adjectives. In the spirit of oversharing, my words at that time were brave, excited and open. Hold onto these words; you’ll keep coming back to them each week.

  4. Write your three words at the top of a page, with the date. Now spend a few minutes writing: what were the times when I was [brave] in the last week? When was I less [brave]? Let yourself feel grateful, or proud, or happy, about the times you were [brave]; think about what you can learn from the times you weren’t.

  5. Then spend a few minutes looking at your calendar for the next week. Where are your opportunities to be [brave]? Write these down. Think about what it might mean to be [brave] in those situations, what support you might need, what might hold you back.

  6. Finish your coffee. Thank yourself for your company. Look forward to the same time, next week.

—

References

Catapult. (2014). Personal communication.

King, L. (2013). The Ladder of Inference : Why we jump to conclusions (and how to avoid it). Retrieved 15 May 2017 from The Synergy Commons: https://synergycommons.net/resources/the-ladder-of-inference/

Maber, T. (2012) Rethinking thinking. Retrieved 15 May 2017 from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KJLqOclPqis

Ten things to do with failure

streetart - a montage of Facebook-style dislike icons

Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better.
—Samuel Beckett, Worstward Ho

Making things happen requires bravery and steadfastness, suggests Theodore Roosevelt in his widely-quoted Man in the Arena speech. Referencing him, Brené Brown suggests that being our best selves requires vulnerability and openness.

Like these two, Craig Johnson (in our assigned course textbook, Meeting the Ethical Challenges of Leadership: Casting Light or Shadow) sees a person’s character as central to developing an ethical leadership style. Johnson asserts, “we need to develop a strong, ethical character… made up of positive traits or virtues.” Rather than engaging directly with our shadow side or potential for negative behaviour, Johnson asserts that as in football “the best defense is often a good offense.” By building stronger virtues (attributes like integrity, courage and wisdom), we become better people and have less need to worry about our selfishness, hubris, or evil.

It’s a view that feels practically useful – it’s easy to see how to focus on and cultivate individual virtues – but a little simplistic. I can’t think of any individual leader from history who has been simply good to the extent that it’s completely overpowered their shadow. Gandhi’s discriminatory class politics, George Washington’s slaves, Mother Teresa’s colonial practices; no-one is perfectly virtuous, your fave is likely problematic. The Stanford Prison Experiment demonstrated that virtue can be context-dependent; evil doesn’t necessarily emanate from evil people but from people under particular pressures.

That said, the idea of cultivating virtues gives us a practical way of interacting with people in more ethical ways. Wisdom, courage, humanity, justice, optimism, integrity, humility, compassion, temperance (avoiding excess) and transcendence (connecting with bigger things than oneself) all have practical relevance to leadership. I’d simply suggest that it’s also important to spend some time reflecting, compassionately acknowledging and working on the parts of ourselves we’re less comfortable with. Back to the football analogy: of course it’s important to have a strong front line (of virtues), but if you neglect the defense (knowing your shadow side) you won’t be able to withstand stronger pressures when they come along.

The textbook’s advice on cultivating virtues is mostly sound, but I found myself shaking my head at this tip:

“Limit the amount of time you spend reflecting on your failures.”

Now, I understand what Johnson was probably getting at: don’t ruminate, don’t beat yourself up, keep moving forward after a failure rather than dwelling in it and staying stuck. That’s all good advice, but for me, reflecting on failure has been an important component of my leadership practice for the last couple of years.

Reflecting on our failures: Fail Club

A few years ago, I completed a Human-Centred Design course with a group of relative strangers, who became friends. Working through a design challenge about how we might support social entrepreneurs, we explored the pressures that are faced by leaders in beginning and sustaining social initiatives. Failure was a key theme of our research: people’s fearful relationship with it, and the necessity of open to it when trying new approaches to solve old problems.

Finding ways to support this awkward dance with failure seemed like a promising solution to our design question. It also felt like something we craved as a group, and in the end we developed Fail Club for ourselves.

Fail Club, contrary to Johnson’s advice, is all about reflecting on our failures. We put time aside specifically for this purpose: sharing, analysing, empathising, learning from each other. Fellow founder Imogen spoke at Creative Mornings a while ago about how Fail Club works and how it’s helped her cultivate self-compassion.

By reflecting on where we’ve gone wrong, we learn about ourselves. Failure can be a way into questions of identity, what we value and prioritise, and the patterns we repeat. Here are:

Ten things to do with failure

  1. Accept their lessons. Learn from them – know what to avoid next time, where you need to grow, what you are self-sabotaging because part of you knows it isn’t right. Let them strengthen you, and thank them. Start a to-don’t list.

  2. Listen to them. Sit with them and share tea. Be curious about what’s deeper; peel back the layers. What did you fail at? Why was that a failure? Why did you fail at that thing? So what was the real failure? Explore. Often what’s behind surface failures are buried insights: old stories we tell ourselves, failure to prioritise our own needs and boundaries, unresolved relationship difficulties that have grown bigger over time.

  3. Surrender to them. Some things are meant to fail. Let them, instead of trying to fix or control everything. Try to see them coming, name them, consciously let them go. Fail harder.

  4. Laugh at them. The story of my last ACC claim was this: an amazing failure at relaxation. I slipped getting out of a bath (set up with candles, bubble bath, mindful breathing, etc) and fell straight onto my cup of tea. I had impressive cup-shaped bruising for a couple of weeks, and a small fracture. I don’t recommend this – it was quite painful – but I also find it hilarious. Some failures are funny. Let them teach you how to take yourself less seriously.

  5. Reframe them. In failing, what went right? Maybe you learned something necessary, maybe it strengthened your relationships. Was it really a failure? Sometimes vulnerability can feel like failure. Sometimes a result you’re seeing as imperfect is perfectly adequate and meets everyone’s standards but your own.

  6. Allow for them. When you’re experimenting or trying something new, leave room for a certain amount of failure. Add contingency costs to your budget. Keep your plans flexible. Allow time for trying, and don’t expect to get everything right the first time.

  7. Build on them. Kintsugi is a Japanese art of repairing broken ceramics with precious metals. In highlighting and celebrating failures, the result can be more beautiful than the original object. When things fail: see where they broke, don’t try to hide those cracks, rebuild things differently to be even more remarkable.

  8. Heal from them. Failures might be helpful, but they still hurt (even when they’re less physical than broken ribs). Take time to nurse your wounds, and be kind to yourself. Remember “failure is a bruise, not a tattoo” (Jon Sinclair).

  9. Make reparations. If your failure affected other people, don’t let your hard feelings (shame, guilt, self-denigration) get in the way of apologising or making it right. Get over yourself and act.

  10. Share them. When we pretend failure doesn’t happen, we all lose the opportunity to learn. In this TED talk, David Damberger of Engineers without Borders shares why development NGOs often don’t talk about their failures, and how changing this pattern can lead to transparency, collaboration and innovation.

So, why dwell on failure? In my experience it’s been a way of cultivating some of the same virtues that Johnson talks about, and others. Courage to face the fear of failure (which is often worse than the actual experience of failure), humility, empathy and genuine connection with others, comfort with vulnerability, flexibility, and self-compassion. By sharing failure, we share in the lessons we’ve learned from them, and we build a clearer understanding of the fact that we’re all human and fallible, and all trying our best.

—

References

+Acumen. (2017). Introduction to Human-Centered Design. Retrieved from +Acumen: http://www.plusacumen.org/courses/introduction-human-centered-design.

Brown, B. (2012) Listening to shame. Retrieved from https://www.ted.com/talks/brene_brown_listening_to_shame.

Damberger, D. (2011). What happens when an NGO admits failure. Retrieved 18 May 2017 from TED: https://www.ted.com/talks/david_damberger_what_happens_when_an_ngo_admits_failure

Engineers Without Borders. (2017). Admitting Failure. Retrieved from https://www.admittingfailure.org/.

Fail CLub. (2016). Fail Club. Retrieved from http://www.failclub.co/.

Jobson, C. (2014). Kintsugi: The Art of Broken Pieces. Retrieved from Colossal” http://www.thisiscolossal.com/2014/05/kintsugi-the-art-of-broken-pieces/.

Johnson, C. (2017). Meeting the Ethical Challenges of Leadership: Casting Light or Shadow (6th ed.). SAGE Publications: USA

M.S.R. (2017). The spectre of slavery haunts George Washington’s house. Retrieved from The Economist: http://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2017/01/first-president-slave-owner

Mscratch. (2015). Problematic Fave. Retrieved from Know Your Meme: http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/problematic-fave.

Parry, I. (2015). Why we all need a Fail Club. Retrieved from Creative Mornings: https://creativemornings.com/talks/the-infographers/1.

Roosevelt, T. (1910). Citizenship In A Republic. Retrieved from http://www.theodore-roosevelt.com/trsorbonnespeech.html

Roy, A. (2014a). Arundhati Roy accuses Mahatma Gandhi of discrimination. Retrieved from The Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2014/jul/18/arundhati-roy-accuses-mahatma-gandhi-discrimination.

Roy, A. (2014b). Debunking the Gandhi Myth: Arundhati Roy. Retrieved from The Laura Flanders Show: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4-yMiBGBOe0.

Varagur, K. (2016). Mother Teresa Was No Saint. Retrieved from Huffington Post: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/krithika-varagur/mother-teresa-was-no-saint_b_9470988.html.

Zimbardo, P. G. (2017). Stanford Prison Experiment. Retrieved from http://www.prisonexp.org/.

Existential anchors

a dragon tree with tangled roots

Accompanying those practical issues is something to do around meaning and purpose, something to do with who am I, what am I about in this world?
– attributed to Matthew, CEO (research participant) in M. Webster, personal communication (seminar), 2 May 2017.

I attended Mike Webster‘s seminar this afternoon on social work leadership values. The presentation referred to findings from Mike’s PhD research, which sought to articulate a model for organisational leadership within social work in the context of Aotearoa New Zealand. The model he developed uses the metaphor of leadership as a tree: a holistic process with integrated components including the operating context (soil), the leader’s values (roots) and their actions (fruit). We explored one aspect of this model today: values, and in particular the ideas of identity and integrity, understood as:

to be honest about one’s ability (including performance anxiety), demonstrating qualities of reliability, transparency (or authenticity) impartiality, and approachability. These qualities acknowledge the influence of personal identity and integrate personal and professional ethical values by asking “who am I?” They are shaped by a practitioner’s self-efficacy, genetic make-up, personal, professional and educational journeys and by role model or mentoring relationships.
M. Webster, personal communication (seminar), 2 May 2017.

The presentation invited us to reflect on some of the statements made by research participants. One of the feedback questions was: What significance do we attach to these existential questions posed by some participants in defining leadership: (i) who am I? (ii) what am I about in this world?

The importance of self-knowledge to living a good life is one of the oldest recorded human ideas, and many people wiser than I have written on its broader philosophical implications. Here are smaller, partial reflections I had on why examining identity and developing self-awareness are important for leadership:

Who am I?

The process of leadership happens in relationship between people. In order to effectively engage with and listen to other people’s perspectives, it’s essential to be able to recognise what you’re bringing to the conversation. Your values, background and identity shape the ways that you interpret what you hear; it’s only when you recognise your biases that you can begin to filter out your assumptions.

Particularly for people who come from backgrounds or experiences associated with privilege and cultural hegemony (Pākehā, English-speaking, school-educated, heteronormative, gender-conforming, non-disabled, thin, etc), it can be easy to assume that your perspective is natural, normal or default. That is, when your personal view aligns with cultural norms, organisational policies or hegemonic ideals, it takes more work to understand that it’s subjective, and not the only way of seeing things. It can be easy to misunderstand or misconstrue other perspectives.

So, knowing who you are enables more genuine relationships. It allows you to stand in your own place, firmly rooted in your own soil, while having enough perspective to respect where others are standing and meet them on a more equal basis.

What am I about in this world?

Having a sense of what your life is for – that is, an understanding of your purpose, values and life’s work – guides direction and decision-making. Being clear on your purpose supports you to make choices, and decide where you can compromise; where you need to stay firm. It makes visible your life’s thread and supports you to find the next right step to take.

Purpose is one of the keys to human motivation (according to Daniel Pink (cited in Popova, 2013) and others) and drives leaders to keep doing things. Authentic leadership happens when your sense of purpose is aligned with the ways you behave in leadership roles, and the actions you take.

So, having a sense of what you’re about means you’re more able to lead coherently, based on an authentic sense of purpose.

—

References

Popova, M. (2013). Autonomy, Mastery, Purpose: The Science of What Motivates Us, Animated. Retrieved from Brain Pickings: https://www.brainpickings.org/2013/05/09/daniel-pink-drive-rsa-motivation/.

Webster, M. (2017). Personal communication.

Out of the office

lacey waves

I’m off work for a few days, taking time to catch up with myself and reconnect with my priorities.

The time away has also been a chance to catch up with university readings and online discussions. One of our conversation starters was Kouzes & Posner (2003)’s ‘credo memo’ exercise.

—

Imagine (the exercise invites) you are about to take a 6 month sabbatical, all expenses paid by your organisation. (It stretches credibility to imagine this fitting into the annual budget of our non-profit organisation, but let’s just imagine for the purposes of this thought exercise).
Unlike some sabbaticals no work is to be undertaken. You will not be permitted to communicate to anyone in your agency in any way, including electronic means. (No PHONE!?)
There will be just you, a few good books, some music and your family or a friend.

Before you depart, your colleagues need to know what principles, values and beliefs you believe should guide their decision-making actions in your absence. You are required to write these down in 100 words or less.

—

I felt a little twinge of anxiety on reading this. Leaving work behind last week, I knew I wouldn’t be gone for six months, and that I’d only be as far away as a global roaming-enabled cellphone call. Even so, it felt a bit hard leaving behind a busy workload, not being sure whether I’d left people with enough guidance or information to keep things going.

The exercise was an interesting reality check. You can’t prepare people for every eventuality or leave every loose end tied up, especially if you’re planning to be away for a longer stretch of time. What could you leave with people that would guide their decisions so they would be somewhat aligned with, even if different to, your own?

I’m sure in reality I’d try to leave a detailed plan, a list of responsibilities and goals. However (for the purposes of this imaginary six month holiday), you can’t know what issues or opportunities might come up over that time. Leaving people with a set of guiding principles, and the autonomy to interpret them in the most meaningful way, would allow for flexible responses and application of their own judgement.

Here were my hundred words:

—

Be inclusive in design and decision-making. Be open to, and respectful of, others’ expertise, whether it’s book learning or lived experience. Listen.

Celebrate differences. Trust each other: assume and extend good intentions in dealing with others, even if you don’t understand where they’re coming from.

Keep a strong strategic vision, but be adaptable in how you achieve it. Be brave in pursuing excellence and trying new ideas.

Lastly, be kind and keep your actions aligned with your purpose. Let the things you do, and the ways you do them, contribute to building a society that is more equal and accepting.

—

Reference

Kouzes, J., & Posner, B. (2003). The credo memo. In Credibility: How leaders gain and lose it, why people demand it (pp. 62, 63). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.